the new annotated sherlock holmes the complete short stories

Sadly, Baring-Gould did not live to see publication of his greatest work, and as a result, occasional errors were not corrected. Yet it had its idiosyncrasies, with the stories arranged in the controversial chronological order created by Baring-Gould and with footnotes that embraced, in many cases, Baring-Gould’s personal theories regarding the life of Holmes. In later years, as I avidly collected things Sherlockian, I dreamed that someday I, too, would produce an annotated version of the Canon.īaring-Gould’s Annotated Sherlock Holmes remained in print for more than twenty-five years and became the cornerstone of every Sherlock Holmes library.

More importantly, the books introduced me to the idea of Sherlockian scholarship, the “game” of treating the stories as biography, not fiction. This magical pair of volumes entranced me and led me back to the stories that I had enjoyed when I was young(er) and had subsequently forgotten. Baring-Gould’s The Annotated Sherlock Holmes, published the previous year.

IN 1968, WHEN I was supposed to be engrossed in law school studies, I received a gift of William S. ”Ĭhronological Table: The Life and Times of Sherlock Holmes “I STAND TO WIN A LITTLE ON THIS NEXT RACE.

The new annotated sherlock holmes the complete short stories